The Boatyard Grill

After a perfect 4th of July weekend exploring the falls in Ithaca, we wanted to find a nice restaurant for our last dinner before we headed back home. After seeing some reviews and photos, we decided to go to this place. We did a "call ahead" around 3pm to hold a table for 9pm outside. When we arrived, we were seated right away. The place was absolutely beautiful! Literally on the lake, where boats docked but there weren't boats actually blocking views of the lake. The outside had a white tent, in case it rained and everything was well illuminated. After giving our orders, we went for a stroll of the area. On the side, near the bar, there was live music, and near the edge of the lake, some lounging chairs. The waiter was awesome, his suggestions were on point! The food was absolutely delicious, everything was absolutely perfect and not expensive at all. I would definitely come back, no question about it!

Food was excellent! Have gone twice in the past two weeks. Highly recommend the stuffed shrimp, wedge salad and salmon. Drinks seemed a bit on the week side, but where are they not, really. I have never really experienced a "melt in your mouth" food, but the scallops introduced me to it. They were amazing! Kids got to feed the ducks on the water, service was friendly and attentive, both times we went we had no more than a 5 min wait.

We went there for the first time yesterday for lunch. The service was over the top excellent! The tuna was a bit overcooked and we had to send it back to the kitchen for a new one. They made up for it and more! We cannot express how happy we were with their customer service. Kudos!

It is tucked away from the road a bit which gives it a nicer and more relaxed vibe. It is right on the water for great outdoor summer eating. The food is delicious and fair priced, especially considering it is a bit more upscale. The New England clam chowder was perfect. The coconut shrimp are few in quantity, but big in size and taste. The Loaded Sheppards Pie is ridiculously good. It looks small, but it is packed with steak. You will not be disappointed. Our server was on point and sweet as pie too. You can't ask for a better experience.

I was there on a Monday evening. They don't take reservations but they have a call ahead policy. I had called ahead and we were seated at the time we requested. The place was packed and it was noisy.

Service was good and staff was friendly. We did not have to wait too long for dinner to be served.

I had the scallop stuffed shrimp. You get 3 shrimp and 3 scallops. It was cooked just right but the sauce had a slight pre-made, store bought taste to it. The wine list is OK but needs to be expanded. Dessert was delicious. I had the NY style cheesecake. The portion was just right.