Papa John's Pizza

I love the pizza at this location, always cooked good and not burnt. I live closer to the one in the University, but go out of my way to go to this location because its better. However, the last two times I called it in and they told me how long it was going to be it was at least 15-20 minutes longer, very disappointed.

I love this place. They have never not even once gotten my food wrong. I typically order once every 3 weeks or so. They are also super fast. When the app or web site gives you an ETA they are always on the early side of it or right before, which is great. I wanted to take a star off because of all the hidden costs when you buy a pizza but it's not this locations fault and i didn't wanna punish them for corporate rules they follow. If you order a pizza for 10 expect to pay about 20$. 10$ for a pizza....4 dollar delivery charge and then the tip. I don't get why they charge that, they didn't used to. I guess if you picked it up it would eliminate th problem, but if I'm getting in my car to go get food, it's not pizza. Pizza is for when I'm home, hungry, and don't wanna cook or go anywhere.

This is hands down the best Papa Johns in the area. We have frequented many Papa Johns in NJ/NY area and none compare to the quality of the Edison Square location. We order our food well done (chicken/pizza) and they get it right everytime. Their pizza never has a raw doughy taste/smell. The staff are typically friendly.

Love this location. I always get the same thing (garlic knots) and they always make it delicious. It's about consistency when it comes to exceptional service and this one has it!
Always great service and they listen to what you want down to detail when it comes to packaging and always does it right ! Will always come here for food when I'm in the area.