Mitzi Lous

This might be my favorite pizza place in Athens right now. If you like Avalanche, keep going there, but for all their myriad of custom pizzas, I find them bland. Mitzi's serves up a nice cheesy (and greasy) pizza with some powerful pepperoni. That is the basic pizza I use to judge a place by. The crust is also thin and crispy and my last one has a bit of char to the toppings which I liked.

I am visiting from Columbus. We usually get Courtside pizza but decided to try something new. This was delicious! The crust is super thin and the cheese and toppings are delicious. We also ordered a salad and was impressed with all the pepperoni that came in it as well. We could never get quality like this in Columbus like this for the price! We will definitely try it again when in town.( we are eyeballing some of the sandwiches). They were also incredibly friendly when we picked it up.5 stars plus!

If you haven’t had Mitzi Lou’s Pizza, you are missing out!

This place just took their place as our new favorite pizza shop!

Their subs and pizzas have plentiful toppings and are absolutely delicious!

Had lunch from here for the first time today. I’m very impressed with the portion sizes, prices and quality of food. Will definitely become a regular. They also made everything exactly how it was ordered which is rare in this area.

Mixed feelings here. Probably the best pizza I've found in the Athens area. Reasonably priced, always hot, generous toppings, and I love their flakey, pastry-like crust.

However, no matter what method I use to order - our order is wrong every single time. Even trying to order online where they have built-in customization options, they just ignore it. Tried over a handful of visits & keep getting the same results. If they could get this right, I would probably be ordering here almost every week.

Unfortunately due to dietary restrictions, I don't think we can keep coming here if they can't follow simple modification requests.