Thompson Ninety-Nine

We spent the weekend up in roscoe hillside cabins and wanted somewhere nice to go for dinner on our second night and we heard about the Thompson Ninety-Nine. This place was fabulous! The service was amazing not only our waitress but all the staff any time someone walked past asked us if we wanted refills on water or drinks and if we wanted them to remove empty dishes for us. We both got steaks I got the ribeye and my husband the bacon wrapped filet with a lobster tail on top. Both were mouth-watering delicious but to top it off I believe it was the manager or the chef before we even got a chance to eat came to our table and told us he didn't like how the lobster tail was cooked and brought more out for my husband at no charge. I have never had a place go that above and beyond to make sure a customer was satisfied! This experience alone will be the reason we return to coshocton!

My wife and I and another couple dined at 6pm on Saturday. We had appetizers and then ordered our meal. My wife had the salmon, I had the halibut, the other couple had a steak and the fettuccine alfredo. Everyone's meal was great, but mine. The halibut came out without the chardonnay creme sauce. I asked the waitress about it and she didn't know about it. Always said it was her 1st week. Took it back and it came out with some extremely hot sauce like Tabasco on it. The halibut was so dry I had to drink water with every bite. Also I ordered a wedge salad instead of the side salad and she told me it would be an upcharge, ok. When I got the bill, I was charged the full price of the wedge salad $9. NOT an upcharge. Waitress told me she worded it wrong. I wouldn't have ordered it knowing I would have paid full price for it. She just said sorry. Didn't ask for manager because all were celebrating Valentines Day that evening. Terrible meal and experience for me.

Very nice restaurant! A little pricey, but they have a large variety of food on their menu and everything we had was top notch.

It's a lovely restaurant that has a different ambience than what you normally find in Coshocton. There's a classy bar, private area and the tall booths you find at many steakhouses. The menu has all your pub staples, but sets itself apart with a large seafood menu. The staples are also done with a bit more finesse than you'd normally find. Service is a bit slow, but everyone is super nice. Everything is kept really clean. There's a big range in prices, so anyone can dine here. Definitely recommend stopping in either for a special occasion or just to relax.