Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery

Wish I could say I liked it more, but pizza was underwhelming. It was primarily a garlic pizza but it had no taste, not even garlic. Crust was thinner, dryer, and tougher than I expected. The baked goods seemed good, and the staff were friendly. I'll give it one more try, but would hope for better, slightly more bready crust and way more flavor in the sauce and toppings.

They say seeing is believing! I saw 5 star rating and seen that it is correct. So I'm paying it forward.
Second time around. Environment is cozy, friendly peeps with delicious baked pies. Love it.

Thanks Tyler for the tour and treats.

Great bakery! Everything we've tried tasted so good and fresh. Highly recommend the cinnamon rolls and blueberry chocolate chip bars. Great customer service!

I placed an order, it was a little drive to this place through rush hour traffic but I eventually picked up the pizza and got home. Overall its hard to think of the last time I had a pizza that was genuinely this good. Everything tasted fresh, the dough, the cheese, sauce, pepperoni and mushroom. The combination of everything was just amazing. Its hard to put into words how great the pizza was. 5 stars for Tyler's Pizza and Bakery!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Might be the best pizza in Columbus, not kidding.

Awesome pizza and baked goods. They make their own pizza crust daily, and cut the vegetables and shred the cheese when you order your pizza. Baked goods made in the shop every day, sometimes still warm from being just baked. Everything is always so fresh. Staff is very friendly also. ????