Asterisk Supper Club

This is my new favorite place! I love the atmosphere, which is cozy and beautiful. I love meeting people there for Afternoon Tea - which feels so indulgent, but is very well-priced.

Their menu has a large variety of items, and can appeal to the pickiest of eaters, and those with dietary restrictions. I'm a vegetarian and have no problem finding good options from which to choose.

Their bar is gorgeous - brought from somewhere in the Western U.S. And the bartender is fantastic! They make incredibly good drinks.

Their tea selection is broad as well, and served in beautiful tea pots and cups and saucers.

Please check it out! You will be happy you did.

Food was pretty good. Its very loud and crowded and you wind up sharing a long table with strangers. But its cozy and service is quick. Worth going for the expierience but I wouldn't go back just for the food.

Great ambiance. Great service. Friendly staff. Food needs some more work though. I went on the suggestion of a friend who hadn't been since the menu and chef change. Maybe they should consider changing it back.

First of all, this place is beautiful. I have to admit though that it is beautiful in a way that's probably particular to me. If you are eclectic like me you will love it. This place is such a blend of tastes and styles that are deftly blended together. Super neat.

So adorable! I was recommended this restaurant by a former Otterbein grad and it was an amazing suggestion. Their hot tea selection was great (Ginger Chili as a seasonal selection was a surprisingly delicious choice). The grilled cheese and tomato soup combo was the perfect piece of comfort on a chilly afternoon. Their appetizers were big enough for a light course (tacos and tuna were delicious).
Walls lined with TONS of books and used for menu holders made for a super cozy atmosphere. The servers were super cheerful and pleasant. We'll definitely be coming back. Such a gem!