Nicolinni's Chophouse

Well we made it tonight. Had dinner at Nicolinni’s Chophouse. It was FANTASTIC! I had the seafood medley and I was loaded with shrimp, scallops, mussels,clams, calamari and white sauce pasta!! Roni had lasagna. The greens had sausage with a hint of garlic. This is a great addition to our restaurant portfolio here in Ytown. #supportlocalbusiness #tasty #love #life

Last nights meal was incredible. The scallops were huge and very tasty. I can’t say enough about the orange “old fashion” drink. You’ll love it here. It’s a must go to.

When returning home to Youngstown it’s all about eating quality Italian food, and Nicolinni’s did not disappoint!

We dined here the day after Christmas and the Chicken and Greens was recommended. It’s heaven in a bowl since I don’t get anything like this in Atlanta. Crunchy, garlicky greens atop small lightly pan friend chicken medallions in a cream sauce. What more could you ask for? My wife’s Pasta Giada was a hit and she kindly shared. Mom’s ravioli and meatballs were traditional, but the sweet sauce was a standout and tender hand-rolled meatballs. The complimentary amazing bread, pesto, and salad make up for the above average pricing for this area, plus it’s a definite take-home main portion. Our server, Hannah, was so kind, attentive, and kept an authentic smile the entire time. I’m already looking forward to my next trip here! Thank you and Happy New Year!

One of the rare occasions I wish I could give 6 stars. Wonderful dinner on a Friday night. They were busy but we were immediately seated. Prompt, friendly and professional service throughout. Our server was superb. The main menu was unique and there was a "specials" menu. Salad was served in a large bowl for the table to distribute. The house sweet vinaigrette dressing was excellant.
Entrees were delivered 12 min after ordering and they were great. I chose a unique chicken-applejack with butternut ravioli an an apple reduction. Out of this world. My partner had egg plant parm with angel hair pasta. The red sauce was a bit sweeter and thinner than I like but still well above average. We splurged on a cinnamon roll cheesecake that was perfect with fresh whipped cream.
The server was attentive throughout.
The check for 2 with wine was about $65. I consider that a great value.
Nicolinni's is definitely on our fine dining rotation. Probably the best meal I have had since moving to NE Ohio 6 months ago.
We will definitely put Nicolinni's at the top of our fine dining rotation.

Nicolinni's is top-notch! The service was excellent, the food was delicious, and the atmosphere was quite comfortable. It's definitely a fancy restaurant, so expect your food and drink to be somewhat pricey. That being said, everything we ordered was delicious!! Around the table, we had ordered the Whitefish Marsala, the Loaded Frenched Pork Chop, the Chicken and Greens, and the Chicken Giada. They were all prepared beautifully and were packed with flavor! You will receive nice sized portions for your money, so that's a plus. You can expect to pay $20-$30 per person for pasta dishes. The steaks and chops are a little higher but are definitely worth it as my pork chop was huge! It's definitely a good place for date night. We went as four adults and were very happy. I did not see any children there, nor did I see a children's menu. Our server was great! He was attentive and accomodating even though they were extremely busy. All in all, it was a great experience.

Food was very good. HOWEVER they close at 9PM but this also means that while you're still in the building you're not allowed to order drinks. I.E. we were at our table at 9:20 PM and our server took our drink order then came back and said "I'm sorry but we can't serve you after 9pm."... our server was cordial and very professional, but I feel we should have been informed prior to ordering.