Park Street Pizza

BEST homemade pizza in Sugarcreek. We visit Amish Country every year and this is our favorite! The staff is so helpful and kind. Their sauce is a secret recipe, so I always buy a quart to take home. It's so delicious! If you are in town, you have to go!

More awesome food! Never disappointed!

I posted this review a while ago. I gotta share more! We just got back from a business trip and had a craving for pizza and wings. One phone call and 45 minutes later we had what had to be some of the best pizza and wings in the country!! Not to mention fantastic service! This is the result of not only the desire to build a great business but obviously great leadership. I can't say thanks enough for the opportunity to deal with another business in my area that strives for excellence! Not to mention holy smokes the food is amazing!!!!

Best pizza for miles! They feature a great menu with seasonal selections. Excellent gluten free crust. Place is always busy but staff is friendly and service is great!

The quality of the food here has always been outstanding in our experience. From a BBQ Chicken pizza, to a Reuben pizza, to a surprisingly yummy side salad, we've always been happy.

We've only ever gone here on a Saturday, and this one was the busiest but it was a short wait in the lobby and a reasonable wait at the table. Our pizza, wings, bread sticks, and loaded fries were delicious.

Expect a wait. Pizza is made from fresh ingredients. Salads are awesome. It is unlike any other pizza shop I've been to. Look the menu over carefully and pick your ingredients from a number of choices. Crust is thin. It's delicious. The wings are the best I've had. We like them bone in and naked. The flavor is awesome. Not a huge amount of fat, lots of meat, and crispy. We drive from Canton just for the wings!