Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow

Very tasty authentic New York style pizza, with robust tomato sauce taste. Unfortunately their pricing has gone up, which makes this option not very desirable. I very much enjoy the three pizza places surrounding this location, all at a reduced price. The pepperoni roll was quite a grease bomb, but very tasty! I would recommend people try this place out, as they may love it more than myself.

Jimmy, his lovely wife, his son and soon to wife run the establishment like a team.

The food is not only really good, it is easily the best in the Tulsa area.

Every time I walk in there, I am treated like family.

Why did I talk about the owners so much? Because the best place in town and every slice, pie, appetizer is prepared, cooked and served with love!

The classic pepperoni is my favourite, but I judge all pizza places by how well they make a Margarita, and it's easily the best I've had.

Anyway, anyone looking for something extremely authentic and absolutely delicious.

I ate here about a month ago and really enjoyed the pizza. Came in today and a slice of pizza is now $7.95. A slice of cheese pizza is $6.50. This pizza was good but I'm not paying $8 for one slice of pizza, I left and went down the street and had sushi instead. It's not that I can't afford your pizza but it's a matter of principle, $8 is just too much for a single slice of pizza. Your pizza was good but I will not be returning.

Clean and nice looking establishment. I had the gluten free pizza. The crust is the one you find at many other places that has the sweet taste at the end. Probably won’t go back because I’m not a fan of that crust. If they made one in house or sourced a better one I would go back.