Piazza Talarico and Papa Joe’s Wine Cellar

Loved the place, very cozy and the staff are extremely pleasant. Great selection of dishes, and of course wines--I was surprised to hear that they make all their own wine. Would definitely eat here again. Highly recommended.

We were three families, from Pgh., Erie, and Charleston SC in town for a wedding. Our niece suggested Papa Joes as a side trip on our way to see the Pirates.When we arrived Joe started by describing the characteristics of each of his wines. It turned out that Joe and the folks from Erie had numerous mutual acquaintences. (It really is a small world) We sampled a number of his wines, and of course we couldn't decide on one so ordered a couple of carafes of different varieties and went out back. Joe's girls made us feel like family and were very attentative to our needs. Food was good and we had an absolutely great time. We would love to do it again the next time we are in town. Thanks Joe, Katie and Beth Talarico, you made our visit memorable.

Friendly service and really good food. Not your average $8.50 hoagie. Very tasty. I really enjoyed the patio out back. Quiet and pleasant. Tasted some of their house-made wine. I think I will get that next time instead of the beer.

Delightful little place with nice patio out back. Thin crust pizza. No tipping policy, and though service was somewhat minimal, it wasn't really missed. Order at the counter and food delivered to the table. Nice to be able to try some unknown, to us, wines before purchasing a generous pour.

I just went here for the first time on Friday. Now, this is a pizza joint, but I went to try the fish sandwich.

The restaurant itself is small, but nice. The menu looked good, but I didn’t try any of the pizza. The service was great, AND they are a no tipping restaurant, which is the greatest thing ever.

Fish sandwich: Honestly, it was just ok. It wasn’t bad, but it was nothing special. They also gave packages of tartar sauce which was a bit of a bummer, but not the worst. Came with a nice side salad and it was $7.49 out the door (remember no tipping needed).

I would definitely go back, and would be excited to try their pizza. The restaurant I would give a 5/5 especially because of the no tipping. The fish sandwich I would give a 3/5. Sounds like the pizza is great though.

No soda water, which was also a bummer.