Brother's Pizza

I am amazed at the other reviews and don't know how my experiences here have been so different. My boyfriend and I visit this Brothers routinely -- I'd say a couple times a month. We love it, every time. The pinball machine is a fun little perk, but we're absolutely there for the food.

I will say that $1.50 for any kind of extra sauce is a little much, but that is my whole list of complaints. We've never had service problems, we enjoy the food a great deal, and I think the pizza itself is fantastic. We usually chat with the waitstaff or owner a while when we're there, and they've been nothing but friendly. Butch may be a little rough around the edges, but he's a good guy and he knows how to cook-- he's often in the restaurant working hard and making something delicious. I don't see what more I could want from a restaurant owner!

When compared to the competing Brothers Pizza locations around town, this is my favorite without question. The ingredients are obviously good quality and fresh, the portions are enough to leave me with leftovers most of the time, and the prices are perfectly fair. Though I've never tried any of the wild specialty pizzas advertised around the dining area, I have heard plenty of other patrons pretty excited about those, too!

I'll continue to be a Hamilton Brothers regular as long as they keep cooking!

Best pizza in State College I am a transplant fron Brooklyn This is the only place I'd get my pizza

Delicious #localpizza. Great service, clean restrooms. Warm environment and the dough balls were the best I’ve had!!!

My boyfriend took me here for my first time and I absolutely love it! Great food and just as good of service. I will go back to this place.