Fenicci's of Hershey

Awesome food, awesome service. We were a large table with a few special requests. The waiter was most polite and professional. Everything was presented as ordered. At no time were we left waiting for anything. If I had any complaints, it would be the dining room was crowded, but it was graduation Saturday so there were probably extra tables on the floor that day. We can't wait to go back. They are family friendly, but not really suitable for small children.

Food is absolutely delicious! Moved to central PA from Staten Island NY. Thought I would never find great Italian restaurant. Fenicci's has made my move complete. Phil the owner was A+++! Vinny loved the fried Calamari you brought to our table to fill his request! Definitely returning! ????

Visit From NYC. Great red sauce, seriously good. Great wedding soup too. Pasta cooked perfectly. Five stars if they had Italian bread from Philly and skip the rolls & butter. Eggplant a little too thick sliced so over-fried but still good.

They work so hard! We went there when there was a huge concert in town and they were packed to the brim. Literally people were lined up on the edges of the wall in the bar. The staff maintained the near chaos gracefully. After sitting at the bar for a while we got a table on the restaurant side and it was so quiet!! How did they do that?! We got a bar date and a romantic "candle" lit dinner in one place! Plus the food was so good. Don't get their wines though. They'll sell you a $5 bottle for $40.

Loved their meatballs and their pizza is delicious! Love to go with friends and sit at the bar. I've gone here for years. Typically service is great but they have some new bar staff and it was incredibly hard to get their attention. Missing the old crew!