Poseidon Pizza

If you want delicious basic pizza, this is the place. Thin chewy crust, tasty sauce and cheese. A welcome addition to options in Middletown.

So glad these guys are open. Finally a place good enough to replace Gaetanos. Got a large plain and a large pepperoni with three kinds of peppers. The whole family loved it. WOOOO SPICY!

The local drought of outstanding pizza in our area is finally over. This. This is spectacular pizza! Perfect crisp on the crust, excellent sauce, and perfect amount of cheese. Best enjoyed in the pizza parlor fresh out of the brick oven, but it travels pretty well, though you should give it a quick crisp in your oven when you get home if you live far. Staff are wonderful. Owner is hands on and very engaging. Very proud of his craft. I just wish we had him in Brookhaven instead of Middletown! Best of Delco!

GO THERE NOW. MAKE THE TRIP. Made a 40 minute drive to go here after seeing pictures on Facebook. It did not disappoint in any way. They only opened a few weeks ago and I've been there three times. Each time gets better. There are tables and a counter, all with chairs for inside dining and waiting. The owners are from south Philly and were both working when I went in. The wife was taking orders and could not have been any more sweet and helpful! The husband was making pizzas and he did a great job with ours! My daughter is 4 and even loved the pizza! The mozza luna is easily my favorite mozzarella stick ever. The shape and breading are fantastic and cooked to perfection. On my second trip we had a cheesesteak and vodka parm. The vodka parm is a chicken cutlet sandwich with vodka sauce and we got mozzarella on it. Each were delicious. There is an awesome hand-painted mural of Poseidon with a cheesesteak and it is my absolute favorite place and a MUST go.

The pizza was well worth the wait! We are excited to finally have a new local pizza shop closer to us and with great pies. I would have included a picture but we ate it too quickly. I judge a pizza by the crust and Poseidon nailed it! We will definitely be coming back.