Casa Carlo Italian Eatery

My wife and I came last evening and the place was closed, contrary to the hours listed on their website. We came back today and had a delicious prime rib cheesesteak sandwich. The service was was quick and friendly! We recommend Casa Carlo to others, with the suggestion to call ahead to verify listed hours.

Menu looked so good I didn’t know what to get first. Decided on the Zio Toto which was excellent. Can’t wait to go back, I highly recommend this place. I even grabbed some fresh pasta (which they make in house) and some homemade sauce for dinner tonight!

I don’t even do reviews but this place is seriously so good. Like this is exactly what Lancaster needed. I’m obsessed!!!! You can taste the freshness, the service is amazing. I love that everything is homemade. Top 5 places in Lanc to eat.

So nice to see some authenticity in Lancaster! This place has such good food. The only downside, my sister won't eat alfredo from anywhere else now! She loves this place. I also loved that they have a deli. There's such quality in the meat and cheese choices and they offer some dope desserts. Can't wait to come back!

Stopped by next door for poke and grabbed dessert to go after we tried a sample. Key lime pie and a cannoli. Both were really amazing, some of the best I've ever had. The woman who helped us was really sweet and I could tell she was passionate about the stores a d customers. We'll be back again :)