Original Tony's Pizza & Restaurant

Decent New York-style pizza in a traditional style shop lined with booths. The walls present an eclectic mix of pizza and pop culture-inspired art and vintage movie posters. Pizza itself was good; we went for basic pepperoni and Sicilian slices. The price was exceptional, with three slices and a bottled soda coming in under $15. Will be back.

This place is fairly new to me but has jumped to the #1 spot on my list for pizza . Everything from the dough to the sauce (you can taste that fresh basil) to the cheese. Also my daughter has put the approval stamp on this pizza as well lol. Well done.

Stopped in for a quick bite off of I-80 when traveling from NY to IN. Ended up ordering baked meals instead. The lasagna could have easily fed two of us! The guy working the counter (maybe the owner) said that location had only been open a couple weeks. The locals are sure to enjoy having Tony’s in their area.

Me & my husband are on vacation & we were both craving pizza , this place exceeded our expectations! We got the everyday deal which comes with garlic knots, wings, & a large pizza. The wings were our favorite part they were the best wings we've ever had! The pizza & garlic knots were amazing as well. The place is very put together & cute & staff was super friendly so happy we ate here! We will be traveling back specifically for this pizza place!