Mamma's Pizza & Subs

Great food. Good atmosphere, decent prices, friendly staff.

Omg when i get back up there to see my family thats the first place we go great tasting pizzeria place has little bit of everything i can taste it now. Love it!!!

Hard to say enough good things about this place. It's clean, the staff is cheerful and courteous, and the food is turned out quickly and in good order. Oh, and, the food! Fabulous. One of the best damned places for traditional American pizza.

Big round of applause for them as they are open till 11:00pm on Friday and Saturday. Every flippin' place in Cumberland County rolls up its sidewalks around 9pm (ya shameful grannies!) so Mamma's is a delight... even if you do have to ride up to New Bloomfield!

So, go! Why are you still reading this? Go, go, go!

All the years I've been going to this location for pizza and has been quite good. Today is the exception. It's Saturday afternoon 5:30. We order a medium pizza extra sauce half cheese half peppers onions and mushrooms. The mushrooms are from I can. I will not order them again. The whole bottom of the pizza was burnt almost black. When my dining partner inquired they said that sometimes happens. I've eaten at other pozza places in the area and have never had this happen. Since I live in this area I will probably go back but next time I will be sending it back if it's black one the bottom. And next time I will take a photo of it.

We gave them another try after a couple of negative experiences. The food has been very good since then. It's also nice to be able to call past 8 pm and not get an attitude like they did before the change in management.