Fat Baby's Pizza & Subs

The Fat Baby pizza was great with plenty of toppings. My wife loved her vodka pasta and actually cleared her plate. Their garlic knots were tasty. Service was prompt and took good care of us. Best of all the price was what you expect to pay for pizza.

Fat Baby's was recommended to us by our host and we liked it so much we'll be making a second trip this week.

We each got a slice of pizza which were impressively large. My wife got pepperoni and I got BBQ chicken, both of which turned out great. We also got the garlic knots which even our picky toddler enjoyed.

Just visiting the island and this was our second stop! Quick friendly service and great affordable prices. And the food was good too! Would absolutely advise folks to give them a try. It’s definitely worth it!

Really really really good pizza. Flavor is great!! The Californian sandwich had a bit of a kick that .Ade the sandwich. The Hawaiian pizza was perfect. The big baby was a great supreme pie. The crust is the best part of all of them, with the best example of a crispy crust I ever had. I loved it!! First time and I'll be back

This is an awesome place. It is locally owned and operated. They have the best food and prices in town. They have pick up and eat-in. They are super friendly. We ate there 3 times during our week stay. Changed up getting different things on the menu and there was nothing I would not recommend. They locally source vegetables and grow their own herbs. Very fresh food. They also make their own mozzarella fresh. You can not go wrong eating here.