Sergio’s Pizza

I don’t typically leave reviews but had to share my experience. I ordered through Uber Eats and got the Everything Pie. I ordered 1 and got 1 free so I wasn’t getting my hopes up. But when the driver handed me two pizzas that weighed well over ten lbs. I was impressed. I sat the pizzas down and opened the box and was amazed. I have had Chicago deep dish in Chicago and I have had New York style thin crust in New York, and I have never had pizza this good. They were piled high (about 1-1.5 inches thick of all kinds of meats and cheeses. The pizza crust was perfectly toasted. I am a big guy and was really hungry and I had to force myself to eat 3 pieces! A++++. Awesome job!!! Order and you won’t be disappointed!

The best experience! Best price in town. True New York pizza, reminds me of Brooklyn back home. Service was amazing-Yuri delivered it on time and it was fresh! I used their catering service.

Really enjoyed our pizza at Sergio’s today! Great flavor! I wish it was fresh mushrooms instead of canned but it was still good! This definitely reminds me of pizza in New York, especially the crust! We will be coming back!

Garlic knots were really good. Pizza was tasty, crust was light and sauce had good flavor. I like that they had a lot of options to choose from, they have pizza, pasta, even calzones. Knowing this, I will definitely try something different next time. I thought it was cool that they offer individual slices too. Wait wasn't long, about 15 minutes from when order was placed to when we got it at our table. One thing I will mention is that they only have 5 tables and barstools for seating. If you have a big party or if you catch them during a rush, it may not work for you to sit down and eat.

It's definitely better than Dominoes any day. Give it a try.

Absolutely love this place. Nicest staff, family owned, and delicious thin crust pizza. We will definitely be back. Buffalo rocks. Grandma pizza rocks. We came on a busy Friday night after Wicked Peel told us it would be a 5 minute wait and we still hadn’t been seated after 20 min. We walked into Sergio’s and were eating pizza within 2 minutes. Then we just trying more slices. Love that they sell by the slice so you can try a bunch! Like a pizza tasting party.