Build Your Own Cookie

I saw this place a few years ago when I was visiting Chincoteague, but didn’t get the chance to try it then. Now, years later I finally got the chance to try and it was everything I dreamed it was. Cookie and ice cream were delicious and lots of options to choose from. The size of what you get is great for the price you pay. A must-have on our next Chincoteague trip!!!

Amazing cookie, delicious ice cream, and awesome customer service! I will definitely return if I am ever back on the island.

Choosing from the large variety of cookies, ice creams and toppings is half the fun. Expect a queue on holidays. Very tasty, but the cookies are only warm - not hot out of the oven.

We were apprehensive when we saw the prices with no pictures or any idea of what we would actually get when we ordered. The cookies are about 4 inches in diameter and about a half inch thick. They are very dense, chewy, and overly sweet. The single scoop of ice cream was mounded up and the equivalent of several (maybe 4) regular packed scoops. We all ordered the 1 cookie + 1 scoop + 1 topping. I had a salted caramel cookie, salted caramel truffle ice cream, hot fudge topping, and whipped cream with a cherry. It was served in a square plastic take-out box, which was nice - we could've saved any left overs if we'd had them or transported it without making a mess. The line was long and parking was at a premium. The cookie and ice cream both had a nice concentration of salted caramel flavor and bits, but it was absolutely sugar overload! I wish I had ordered a kids size or shared with someone rather than having one to myself.

We had it last year and we couldn't wait for our trip this year to enjoy it again. Absolutely worth any wait. The owner and employee's have great customer service skills. The cookies and ice cream are delicious ????. What a wonderful combination.