Jamestown Pie Company

Amazing pies! We got chocolate pecan, traditional pecan, key lime, and BlackBerry peach. They were so good! The owners were fantastic and so friendly! I loved to find out they ship! Very reasonably priced as well!

The only thing that would make this better would be a restroom facility. And maybe a small pavilion in case of rain for people who wanted to stop and eat their luscious pie on site. My first time there, I had an individual strawberry-peach pie. It was sunny out, perfect temperature, and add to that shade and butterflies playing around the edge of the outdoor seating area, it was like a perfect taste of heaven. It looks like the majority/all business is take out as it is counter order and go, but I could see their pies as the base of a wonderful family picnic.

It's 75 degrees out, sunny, and you're sitting on a picnic table bench eating a personal-sized strawberry-peach pie in the shade while watching native butterflies flutter around. There's nothing complicated or strange about pie and they make a good one, too. This is a place of no embarrassment. It's easy to spot, there is ample parking, and you can people/car watch as the world goes by.

We stopped in today because of the amazing reviews. The food was phenomenal! We had a sausage and pepperoni pizza and an Italian! Well worth it. No indoor seating but it was cool enough to sit outside. Great little place. We will absolutely come again when visiting!

Loved this place. A mandatory hole-in-wall food stop for locals, tourists, or anyone just passing through. Their motto is "Because Round Food is Good Food" (and it would make me round, if I lived closer, because I'd be eating there everyday).

The Arno pizza was very good, but their Pot Pies are dynamite. We had the Au Gratin Pot Pie. The crust was amazing and the filling was super rich and creamy with shrimp, scallops, and crab. It's as if Homey comfort food met seafood delight.

Another must have is their Chocolate Pecan Pie. It's like biting into a super-gooey chocolate chip cookie. SO GOOD! (The bumbleberry pie is also great; we recommend getting 3-4 smaller pies so you can try different kinds).

Note: check out their website and call ahead, if you can. The pot pies take a little while to bake, so if you're in a rush you might need to plan accordingly. Also they don't have indoor seating (so if it's not a nice day, you may want to take it to-go anyway).