Classic Slice

My first visit with a couple New York friends. According to them it was as good as home. We killed an 20" between the 3 of us. I'll be back even though it is about 45 mins from home.

I could eat Classic Slice probably every day and be happy. It had been a while since I have been here, so I stopped in for the lunch deal. Slice of cheese pizza and a drink. The slice is ginormous. I am always surprised. As always, very delicious and filling. Best in MKE!

Best Dairy Free/Vegan Pizza in Milwaukee!! (Or maybe anywhere?!) Being allergic to all dairy can really limit your dining options, so when our concierge told us about Classic Slice we headed straight over. The staff were very friendly and knowledgeable about the ingredients and options available for me, and the pizza was DELICIOUS! There were many vegan and dairy free options to choose from, even different kinds of dairy free "cheese"! My boyfriend (who has no such allergies) thought the "real cheese" pizza was just as delicious as i thought mine was, so it must be good! Locally sourced, friendly staff, low key atmosphere, very affordable, delicious Pizza and salad options-- what more can you ask for!?? I might just go back to Milwaukee just for a piece of pizza! Go here!

Always worth the wait for a great slice. Don't recall what it was called, but I had the slice with bacon, chives and kimchi tonight and I'll definitely get that one again! Tasty!

I can't say enough about this place! You can order pizza by the slice or by the pie here. Note that the slices are gigantic, and one slice is more than enough to eat. All the slices are made to order here, so you will not see any pizza slices sitting around that are then heated up once you order them. You'll find the standard (sausage, pepperoni, cheese) pizzas on their menu, but the specialty slices/pies are the way to go! Why not show your true Wisconsin colors and add cheese curds to your next slice? My new favorite is their Detroit style pepperoni. It's tough to find Detroit style in Milwaukee, and they do a really good job of making theirs. I live close by and will definitely be back soon! If you're ordering pickup, I'd definitely call ahead as this place is very popular and can get very busy, especially Friday - Sunday evenings.