Tony & Maria's Italian Pizzeria

This is my favorite restaurant in the whole world!????! I know they work very hard one every thing they do!! There curst is home made as well is the sauce! If you are looking for a place to eat pizza you have to go here and try it! If you don’t like it or even give it a 4 star you are OUT OF YOU MIND for not like this! If you haven’t tried it you are going to try it NOW RIGHT NOW!! ????

Best around. I feel like this is what a real italian pizza would be like. Now ive never been to italy, but this is damn good pizza, even tomorrow.

Ever since I discovered this place I've been a return customer. The price is a bit higher but for what you get it's worth every penny. I've seen complaints about customer service, price, and delivery times. Here's the skinny on those topics. This place gets very busy and hectic so if the phone rings and rings it's because they are swamped. Customer service? They do their best and treat people with kindness. The price. If you are complaining about a $25 pizza with the works then stick to Domino's or pizza hut. This is a real pizzeria. If the cheese slid off it's your fault as they do tell you to keep it level. They use real ingredients from the 100% cheese, unlike Macs and Domino's, to the toppings and dough. Sam's large size is actually smaller than a 12"and they've raised their prices mind you. Tony and Maria's has the right amount of cheese, sauce, and toppings. The taste is insanely great. The crust is bit soggy due to the real ingredients that cause grease to soak into the crust. To me that's not a deal breaker. These local guides with unfound reviews on this place really need to understand what a pizzeria is. Hint it's not the major chains. This pizza will have you saying mamma mia with the amount of fresh ingredients and flavor you get. And again if $25 is too much for you then go elsewhere. This is real people, real pizza, and real taste.

Best Pizza in all of Wisconsin.... I've had many in other places but have yet to find better!!

Anyone who complains about the price should stick to Domino's. I order an X-Large sausage, mushroom, onion, every time I order, it's $45 and worth every penny. You're a damn fool if you think someone in the area has better pizza. This is the best, PERIOD!!