Sheboygan Pasty Company

The pasties were delicious! As a fairly new company the variety of pasty is limited at this time. If you give them a call 24-48 hours ahead of time they can do some personalization if you don't like a specific ingredient inside.

Ordered an Italian and a Sheboygan and amazed how great they were. My dad came from Escanaba and we would always grab pasties while in the UP. I will say these were even better! Glad a 💎 like this was brought to Sheboygan. Highly recommended!

Tried the reuben, the traditional, the breakfast, and the dessert pasties, and they were all OUTSTANDING! We also loved the extra gravy and sauce you can get to go with them. Loved the flaky crust, they are made to perfection! The staff was wonderful and friendly to talk to. We will definitely be back....would probably be their #1 customer if we didn't live so far away. We are pasty loving people!

Amazing! The traditional pasty is so delicious! Closed my eyes and for a moment, thought I was in St. Ignace, Michigan! The spicy Italian is really good, too! I will be back to try the rest of the menu! Thank you for the fantastic meal.

I grew up eating pasties made locally in Southeastern Wisconsin. I truly like those, but they don't hold a candle to real UP pasties. The pasties here are authentic incredible UP pasties. I recommend this place to anyone. Brought my family up while visiting Sheboygan and the food and prices were awesome! We will be back(maybe tonight)!