Fitzgerald's Genoa Junction

What a treasure this place is! A quick trip from Lake Geneva and totally worth it. I am not a fish eater but I ate every bite of this. Will definitely be back.

We have been going to Fitzgerald's for years and have never been disappointed! Always love the fish boil and today we had the corned beef and cabbage for St Patrick's day. Fantastic! This place is like going home ????

This restaurant is inside an octagon house. They have dining both inside and out. They have 4 different meals to choose from which are all you can eat. One is a fish boil cod dinner, BBQ chicken and BBQ ribs. One of them is also a mix. I don't eat fish at all but I ate the fish boil from here. It is a buffet that is reasonably priced but it is CASH only. They also do your drink orders on a separate order. Overall it is a really great place.

I have been going here for 20+ years and their menu hasn't changed and that's perfectly fine. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. Basically you have 2 options...

1. You buy a ticket for all you can eat fish boil
2. You buy a ticket for endless chicken, ribs, and all you can eat fish boil

Fitzgerald's labels themselves as a "Door County" style fish boil. I've never had Door County fish boil so I can't vouch for that but what I do know is that they boil cod till it falls apart and tastes like lobster, give you some red potatoes, little pearl onions, and ladel melted butter over everything. You can also grab some homemade rye bread with salted crust. You can go up for food as many times as you like! Desert is an apple square BUT YOU ONLY GET ONE! Great food, great atmosphere. No complaints.

Love this hidden gem!! Was dying for a Door County fish boil & ran across Fitzgerald's All You Can Eat fish boil with amazing cod! No bones, no skin, homemade coleslaw, homemade dark pumpernickel bread, red potatoes, onions, with as much melted clarified butter as you want & an apple square (dessert) for $15.
If you go with all you can eat BBQ ribs, BBQ chicken & the fish its $5 more. Full bar, outdoor seating & you can watch the fish boil while you eat. Everyone there is so nice & there's even a little gift shop with unique inexpensive items.