Second Salem Brewing Co.

My husband and I were in earlier this week and we had Nolan as our server. He was absolutely FANTASTIC! It got busier and busier as we sat and he handled it like a champ, greeting everyone with a smile and answering all of my questions about drinks. We’ve never had a less than excellent experience here and when I called to compliment our server again, I was greeted by Tim who served us in the summer and delivered the same fantastic service and upbeat attitude. The food is delicious, the building is clean and the staff is always kind! Thank you second Salem for being one of my favorite parts of being in Whitewater!

Nice place to grab a craft beer! My favorite style (Oktoberfest Märzen) just happened to be on tap when I visited, so it was a seasonal surprise! You can also take beers to-go, growler, howler, or crowler (pictured). I didn't order food, so I'm unable to review menu items

Food was amazing. Added bonus they have Ellsworth cheese curds. Food is very reasonably priced and the beer list was diverse and tasty. Staff was fantastic.

We thought any place featuring a Witch motif would be able to offer vegan/vegetarian fare...why those two go together, I don't know. I don't think witches are noted for eating vegan, but I believe Wiccans are generally understanding, compassionate people so we took a chance. Superb Hummus Platter! In fact, I'd go as far as saying it was the best Hummus Platter I've ever seen. Not just a small bowl of hummus with pita slices around it.  A HUGE plate of hummus with an even larger plate of assorted marinated veggies for dipping. Then they had Beyond Burgers on the menu...um...YES! The burgers come with lettuce, tomato and avocado, but no ketchup or mustard or pickle. Fries were good. Our lone vegetarian ordered the Margherita Flatbread and it was quite large, definitely meant for sharing amongst 2 or more people and he said it was super duper good. But it had cheese on it, so he had to eat the whole thing. And he did. My salad had the best balsamic dressing I've ever had because it wasn't sweet. I hate sweet dressings, and this was perfect. It was a giant salad and I cleaned that plate. One of us ordered the brussels sprouts and she said they were delicious. Beers were good too. The glasses had their cool witch logo on it, and one in our group left with a t-shirt from the place. The only knock I have against this place is that their tables are made with pipes that are placed at just the right position for you to bang your knees into as you sit down. Our waitress was vegan! So I didn't have to spend a lot of time explaining stuff - she understood immediately what our needs were, and she was attentive and so nice. We ordered so much food that our bill was over $100 for three of us. WORTH IT!

Was very excited to get to this place. Food was good and some of the beer was good. Did have a few beers in the flight as well as a pint I bought that had a slight off taste. Don’t know if it was the lines or what….just was not as enjoyable. Service was nice and atmosphere was cool. Love the theme and beer artwork.