Lou Malnati's Pizzeria - Now Open!

ordered 2 pizzas and it came to 58.00
not a good value for what you get. I won't return without a good coupon

We ordered on the phone for pick up. We arrived and they had people outside who came to our car. We waited a short time for our food to come out. We ordered the garlic bread, the Malnati salad, tiramisu, and an XL thin crust with sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, and black olives. The pizza was delicious and I would definitely order again. The salad was good but you will have to put it into a bigger bowl to mix it when you get home. The vinaigrette dressing was a little too sweet for me. The tiramisu was really good. The garlic bread was kind of bland but they give you marinara for dipping so that made it much more flavorful.

Pizza is good, but not the same as Chicago’s downtown locations (current Loop resident). The deep dish is much thinner than true Chicago style and cheese was a bit rubbery. The thin crust’s dough was undercooked and droopy. Taste is great but needs to get that Chicago authenticity. Would love to see those key changes to make it the go-to pizza spot in Waukesha.

Just had their pizza tonight. I've been eating this pizza all my life, and this is perfect...well perfect after we recooked it for 15 mins. A bit under cooked for us. The salad is great and fresh. The wings were perfect. Only thing I'd suggest is to have the delivery watch how the pizzas are in their car. The toppings were shifting majorly to one side!

I just ate my first pizza from this location and just WOW! It was delicious! The butter crust was perfect. As someone born and raised in the Chicagoland area, I sometimes find that the Wisconsin locations of Chicago food chains just don't get it quite right, but these guys hit the mark!!! The taste took me right back to my childhood. I look forward to many more pizzas from this location in the future.