Tally's Tap & Eatery

Food is excellent! Such a huge menu, we're going to have to go back several times to try everything we saw that interested us!! Great selection of tap beers and they even have drink and food specials on Saturday nights! Cute little place, great service, definitely recommend!!! Oh and Karaoke on Sat nights!

Solid 4-star local Waukesha bar. Bright but decent atmosphere. Food was good for the most part. Stuffed pretzel wasn't much liked but everything else was good. Decent beer selection. Standard beers but enough craft options to cater to everyone. Waited a long time for service on a Tuesday evening, hence the one star off, but otherwise wouldn't hesitate to come back here.

I was torn between a 3 star and 4 star review. They have good bar food and the bartenders were great. Lots of TVs for watching the game. There were several drawbacks, though. We ordered wings and got all paddles. Not one drumstick. How does that happen? On purpose, obviously. Every side costs extra. Our server asked us if we wanted celery and carrots with the wings, without telling us that they were extra $$. We got 3 bits of celery, and 3 carrots for $1.50. Cheese for the pretzel was $1.75. Yikes. It's not going to break the bank, but it's still nice to know. Lame.

Great place to meet up with friends and hear some live music. The food is really good. I had the grilled cheese and would definitely have it again (though the raw onions are thickly cut and strong). The service is professional and kind. The location is ideal, being close to Milwaukee, but still far from the traffic. There is plenty of available parking around the building for free. The interior of the building is well lit and nicely decorated. Very clean. I would recommend this place for meeting up with family and friends (even children are welcome! This is not a bar/pub atmosphere) and perhaps see if they could cater for a smallish party. Just be aware that it gets very loud on their busy nights. All in all, I would highly recommend Tally's Tap and Eatery.

One of the reviews said its usually a long wait. We were seated as soon as we walked in and it was a Saturday late afternoon at that. This was our first visit. We are from out of state working in Milwaukee and we love trying different places throughout our travels. Our waitress was excellent and the food was fantastic and plentiful. This is one place that is saved in my google maps to return while I am here. I Definitely recommend Tallys Tap & Eatery.