Old Mill Pizza

I don’t understand the negative reviews.. oddly worded , as if made up..? by a disgruntled person.. ? I enjoyed everything.. Cold beer, salads were fresh & crisp.. Pizza was really good.. I enjoyed the decor.. a bunch of cool music paraphernalia hanging everywhere .. I thought the restaurant was spotless.. bathrooms too.. I would recommend trying this place & ignoring the obvious fake negative reviews.. cool tunes were playing as well..

We had salads and my friend took home a pizza. The salad would have been great except that the chicken tasted funky like it came out of a can and then overly seasoned. My friend said later the pizza was just ok. The waitress was nice but we had to ask for a box for the pizza 3 times after my friend told her it was"to go". There was only one other set of customers in there so it wasn't busy. I'd probably go back some day to give it a 2nd chance because I hate judging on a one time occurrence. We didn't see any bugs and the place seemed clean enough when we were there.

Really nice neighborhood pizza joint. The staff is super friendly and accommodating pizza was very good. The owner was there and personally introduced himself. A rare experience when dining out these days. We have already recommended them to friends. We'll definitely be back!

I've been wanting to try this spot for a while and finally did today. I got a small supreme pie. As with most pizza joints in the LR/ NLR area, it's just ok. Not enough sauce, cheap sausage and bell peppers diced so fine you can barely see them let alone taste them. The server was friendly and attentive and gave me a drink to-go. But at 15 bucks for a small? I'm gonna have to say goodnight.

It seems to be a nice place to eat at but of course I had takeout when I got home and taste the pizza it was really good the ranch dressing is the bomb.com the cheese dip I really didn't care for it but I ate some of it I don't like the fact that had a cheddar taste but overall everything was really good