Buffalo Nickel Inc

Hands down the best fish tacos I’ve had in a looong time - and I live on the coast in a beach town. I asked what kind of fish and they said it was cod!? Had no idea cod could taste that good, I would’ve guessed it was locally caught perch or maybe sheepshead. Really excellent. We also ordered chicken nachos which were good but could’ve used more guac and sour cream. The service was great, everyone was very friendly and attentive. Easy pick up option from town so we could get here to try it out. We will definitely be back next time we visit the island! Wish I took photos of the fish tacos!

This is a hidden gem. Our daughter found this place a few months ago. We called and they sent a van to pick us up from the marina area. The food was amazing! The ceviche was the best we have ever had. This will be a must stop on future trips to Catalina!!

Small intimate, quiet place you have to shuttle in to visit. I ordered the Mexican pizza with chile verde and carnitas and one tostada de ceviche. Both food items were good and on point. The drinks on the other hand were both of poor quality, did not drink either and got charged $25 for two drinks we did not consume. The Buffalo milk tasted like a lot of cheap vodka with little to no flavor so the colada tasted like it had no alcohol in it. So we didn't drink them. Didn't even bother taking a pic for the train we didn't like the drinks.

A LOCAL FAVORITE! Try the ceviche! They were so kind and accommodating. This is a perfect, off the beaten path location. They will come grab you from town if you don’t have a ride. Easy golf cart access - took no more than 5 minutes to get there and lots of space for all.

Great food and nice service! We had a burrito, nachos and buffalo milk and they were all really good. It was pretty busy. They do not provide free tap water only water bottles. They have a free shuttle you can call that will pick you up and drop you off, there just might be a bit of a wait for it. I would definitely come back here!