The Penny Ice Creamery

I love this place! Independent locally owned shop. Makes all of their own ice creams from locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Quality ice cream and sorbets with certain staples (Tahitian Vanilla and Dark Chocolate Sorbet) and other flavors that change regularly. We had the Lime Cardamom Cherry Crisp and the Verve Coffee Chocolate Almond Praline with toasted marshmallow fluff topping this time. 😋 So good! Always spotless, indoor and outdoor seating with a fire pit in the outdoor area. Staff are always friendly. Parking can be tricky because of shared lot with Starbuck's, but there is additional parking behind the building.

Indoor seating and outdoor seating are both nice. It’s a great spot after spending time on beach. Their roasted marshmallow topping is a must try. We tried coffee and strawberry ice cream. Flavors are limited but good. Taste wise nothing special but ambience and toppings makes it worth a visit.

First time going to Penny Ice Creamery despite having a giftcard in my wallet for the past few years. It's a little on the pricier side, but the flavors are delicious and unique. The woman who was working that day was an absolute sweetheart and let me try a few different flavors to make sure I'd be happy with the one I got. A little girl before me had gotten the toasted marshmellow topper so on a whim I got it as well - delicious! Worth the experience and visit.

4 stars for adults, 3 stars for kids. Some of the flavors are unique and not your ‘normal’ flavors. Unique flavors we tried, real mint chip (strong!), German chocolate cake and chocolate sorbet (tasted like a brownie?). A little pricey but ingredients are clean and pure.

This is some real ice cream.
First time I had a penny ice cream was at the felton farmers market. Once I saw the verve coffee flavor I knew that's gonna be my new favorite flavor.

This Scott's Valley location was recently opened and the place looks great. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. Their waffle cones are also as fresh as their ice cream because they make them there. Also last time I tried the toasted marshmallow topping and it was fun. A little too sweet for my taste but bet kids would love it.

Service was great and very friendly. Will definitely come back again. Highly recommended