Amato's Pizza Shop

Pizza is good but, in my opinion, not worth the wait nor the hassle of calling over and over again to try to order. Then it is at least a one hour wait or longer. I posted a review of the management of this place and the owner called and blasted me on the phone! He proceeded to say something to my husband. So he has time to read reviews and blast customers but cannot take an order. Again, just my opinion, which is the purpose of a review. Pizza is good but you have to be willing to deal with the patience needed to order and wait. I have had other pizzas in the area just as good.

Best pizza place in town. No I'm not a relative or a friend. This place has fresh ingredients, homemade sauce and dough so if you need to wait a bit longer it's well worth it. It's the only place in town open late as well so show them some love!

VEGAN CHEESE! I cannot even begin to explain how excited I was to find out we’ve got a great new spot in town with amazing NY style pizza AND vegan cheese.

We ordered 2 pizzas on our first order, and they were incredible! Great crust, wonderful sauce, and the vegan cheese was delicious. By far some of the best pizza I’ve had in years.

As a native New Yorker who can’t eat dairy, THANK YOU. We’ve got a new favorite pizza spot in town!

This is THE place for an authentic NY slice in this area. These young owners from Brooklyn know what they’re doing. High quality ingredients and TLC go into every pie, and it shows. Awesome new/old school school vibe. We watched old episodes of The Price Is Right while waiting in their dining room. Highly, highly recommend.