New York Pizza Orange Park

Had to feed family who came into town for my daughter's graduation. I ordered New York pizza, an 18" each of Deluxe and Cheese. Everyone who partook of the pies that evening were very expressive about how good they tasted. A couple of the family members went as far as saying it was the best they've ever had. I still think Renna's is a touch better, but no doubt that New York Pizza is New York good.

Chicken bacon ranch and pepperoni mushroom is my go to and they rock it! Garlic knots are awesome too! I'm picky and this place has great tasting pizza sauce and garlic sauce is amazing! Their sausage is a bit too fennel seedy for me, but that's a personal preference thing so definitely 5 stars all around! Go check it out! My new go to pizza place

I'm 8 months pregnant and wanted some really good pizza. I saw this place one day and ordered it. It was amazing. I'd go here over any big pizza chain any day. Might become one of my weekly spots. Love it. The people who work there are really nice as well.

Best pizza in town! I always get their two cheese and a drink combo! Can’t go wrong! They always have a nice selection of slice pies as well! Very convenient to have slices ready to go within 10 minutes when I’m on the run! Highly recommend the pizza rolls and garlic knots! Food is always fresh and way better than Papa Johns! If you haven’t already try it you’re missing out!