BJ's Pizza & Subs

Came in late onto the island, and was able to order to go. Menu is plentiful with options. Staff are also very friendly as well. Pizza was great, dough seemed mediocre but toppings abundant. We got two salads which were great and an order of the cinnamon bread. Would recommend for later night fare.

We got the Mexican pizza and it is delicious! Really like the refried beans and the sauce. Great combination. We got the Mac and cheese bites with blue cheese and the crab bites are like small crab cakes with real crab. All of it was really good

Well our ordering experience was unfortunately the best part of this location. The food was ok, everything came out at a decent time except the salad which took 35 mins more to make and wasn't worth it. Clearly my ticket got lossed some how. We received no condiments, no cutlery and no napkins which is bad for take out. I had to eat my salad on the beach with my fingers, the burger was dry and wings weren't as flavorful as we'd hoped. We most likely will try them again on a non- holiday to see if they can do better.

Always delicious. You HAVE to order the onion rings. Just like my Mom used to make!! They have all sizes of pizza + lots of combinations of toppings. Their hot sandwiches are super good too. Good beer choices, including Oyster Bay. Never been in the midst of the busy season but I’m sure it’s busy.

It's the only pizza place on the island that I know of and I think they do a great job. We ordered a pizza and a few orders of chicken wings. The pizza was cooked perfectly. The chicken wings are done old school. Fried and tossed is a regular hot sauce. They were great! Very good.