Tarpon Bay Seafood Restaurant

Surprisingly good food for a resort restaurant. Grilled fish entrees were excellent! Tuna ceviche was very good but portion was very small. Would definitely recommend this restaurant if you are staying here.

The best culinary experience...the service (Jason was a true professional who made perfect recommendations) and the atmosphere was relaxing and fun. The best seafood dish I ever - the bacon wrapped grouper - superb. Thank you for making our dining experience and experience to remember!

In general the food was good but not great, except for the salmon ceviche (it was amazing). There were 4 of us and the 2 people who ordered steaks noted that though their steaks were cooked to the requested temperature, the steaks weren’t served to the table hot.

Even with that, I would have rated the overall experience a 4 but the service was exceedingly slow. It took about 20 minutes from the time we sat down for the waitress to come over and take our drink orders. And from there, it was an additional 35-40 minutes before the waitress returned to take our food orders. All of this was unfortunate because I really enjoyed the waitress’s personality. She was very pleasant and engaging.

Service was impeccable, ambiance on the outdoor deck was serene and peaceful, quiet, although it was humid and hot, we got over it. Great wine selection. Food was perfect. Had the flatbread, highly recommend the ceviche, fresh catch was out of this world delicious, they even gave us a free anniversary dessert and accommodated my wife's dairy allergy. We will return the next time we visit Bonita.

We were at Tarpon Bay Restaurant this past Saturday. I have to say, it was one of the best meals we’ve had in a long time! Great service! Peggy was fabulous! Can’t wait to return!