Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar

Our table ordered four different seafood options from the fresh "just caught" fish section. Each one was delicious. Portion sizes were great, sides were delicious. Servers were very friendly and on top of it. We enjoyed the live music as well. Very dog friendly.

Best FRESH SEAFOOD in Tally. I thought I was in South Florida with its excellent taste. Peaceful, perfect, clean atmosphere. Eat in or outside patio. I've been there twice already. I will return, again and again. I simply Love Tally Fish & Oysters Bar.

We had a celebratory dinner here and arrived at 430pm on a Saturday and sat on the patio outside. We loved the atmosphere, our server was great. All 4 of us ordered pick 2 or pick 3 meals: grilled Mahi, fried shrimp, clam strips, blackened red snapper, grilled swordfish and fried red snapper. We ordered multiple appetizers including the conch fritters, grouper bites (very good!), fish house oysters and raw oysters on the half shell. All of the fish was very good. We also got fried okra, cheese grits and fries for our sides which were all very good (especially the fried okra!). Overall it was a five star rating, but I may have given it a 4.5 star because there were oyster shells in about half of the oysters. The food and service were great, but I think it would be beneficial to step up the oyster shucking game! We will definitely be back!

Great food, the waiter was not very knowledgeable.