Mattheessen's

One of the best ice cream shops in the US and Keylime pie, dipped in chocolate, on a stick?! Come on!

Now that’s a cookie! Most oversized cookies suffer from the same issue - they are baked on the outside but by the time you get to the center it’s typically gooey undercooked cookie dough. Thankfully the chocolate chip cookie here was perfect. Baked throughout while still maintaining crunchiness on the outside but still cakey in the inside without being undercooked. This was one of my favorite cookies I’ve had in a long time.

Best key lime pie 🥧 and toasted coconut ice cream. Get them together and thank me later. 😍 Both are made in house for decades according to staff.

Metthessene Ice Cream is an okay spot for Cuban ice cream, though the pies were overly sweet and not to my liking. Unfortunately, the experience was marred by a rude and sarcastic waitress, making it the most unpleasant encounter I've had to date

When we first went to store, it was should have been open but the doors were locked. The lady inside waved gave hand signal as if to say just a minute. Well, we waited outside for at least 5 minutes and she never opened the door. We did go back hours later and she had opened for business. My great nephews enjoyed the ice cream.
I love the way the store is decorated and it’s next to the best breakfast place ever; The Breakfast Club, Too.