Old Town Bakery

Nice local grab and go place. Danishes are delicious, curry chicken sandwich was a little dry but great flavor. Which they would matchstick cut the apples to be easier to eat. Breakfast burrito best protein option, but felt like a lot of tortilla to filling ratio. Good coffee too. Only a bench outside, so recommend taking it Togo. Would return and try the 🥐, guava pastry was super flake, wish it was bigger and had cream cheese.

Best spot for great baked goods and sandwiches! Tucked away in old town this spot came highly recommended and we totally were not letdown. A cute bakery that offers takeaway only. Sticky bun was my fave! Lightness of a croissant with the gooeyness of sticky bun! Perfect match! Very reasonably priced too! We liked it so much we went back twice! Had the Italian sandwich based on a recommendation of a local patron and it didn't disappoint! Make sure you go early as they close at 3 pm and their stuff sells out!

Tip: walk down towards the water to the ferry terminal and you can grab a seat in the shade on the second floor and enjoy your treats/lunch while watching the boats in the marina!

Cute small bakery with homemade pastries. I had a key like pie to go and really enjoyed it. Probably one of my top 3 key lime pies that I tried on the island! They also have these cute shirts for merch that I plan on purchasing upon my return. The staff were also friendly. Great service!

Came here around 11am and they still had a decent selection, although it wasn't fully stocked because of the earlier rush they had.

Was greeted quickly and warmly by the lady behind the counter.

Took a Cheese Danish to go and their last slice of Key Lime Pie. It was heavenly. Would come here again!

Hi Old Town Bakery,

The bakery was close to where I was staying, so I wanted to make a stop. Depending on the day and time you go, the bake goods may be running out pretty quick. The prices are affordable, but you can tell that they made up a lot of prices that were the same. I got the cookie, key lime pie, and baguette.

The chocolate chip cookie has some oats which made it taste different. It’s cookie is not for me sorry. The key lime pie is highly recommended! You’ll need to try it! Lastly, the baguette tastes like any other bakery baguette which is good. Nothing really wrong with it.

Overall, I would want to try more goods next time I come back. Sorry for my harsh review but it’s my honest opinion.