Moondog Cafe

I absolutely love Moondog and have come here multiple times. The burger I had was perfect and filling. A friend that came with me was gluten free, and even her burger without a bum was delicious. The atmosphere is perfect, outside and inside.

During our visit to Moondog Cafe & Bakery in Key West, we had the opportunity to try a variety of dishes, each offering a unique taste experience. The café has a welcoming atmosphere and an extensive menu that caters to diverse tastes.

Appetizers:

We started with the Spinach & Artichoke Dip and were thoroughly impressed. The creamy blend of spinach and artichokes was perfectly seasoned and served with crispy crostini. This dish was a delightful beginning to our meal. Additionally, the Truffle Fries were a hit, offering a satisfying crunch with a rich truffle flavor. The Avocado Caprese was fresh and flavorful, featuring ripe avocados paired with juicy tomatoes and fresh mozzarella, drizzled with a tangy balsamic glaze.

Main Courses:

For our main dishes, we had mixed experiences. The Quiche Lorraine tasted good, with a nice balance of flavors from the bacon, cheese, and custard filling. Unfortunately, it was slightly burned, which detracted from the overall enjoyment. Similarly, the Roasted Mushroom, Truffle & Fontina Pizza had potential, but it was overcooked and the crust was burnt, which made it less enjoyable.

On a brighter note, the Blackened Local Mahi Tacos were delicious. The fish was perfectly cooked and seasoned, and the accompanying toppings added a refreshing crunch and zest that complemented the mahi perfectly.

Dessert:

To finish off our meal, we indulged in the Key Lime Pie. This dessert was the highlight of our visit. The pie had a perfect balance of tartness and sweetness, with a creamy texture and a delightful graham cracker crust. It was a quintessential taste of Key West and left us wanting more.

Service:

However, the service at Moondog Cafe & Bakery could use some improvements. Throughout our visit, we noticed a lack of attentiveness from the waitstaff. We found ourselves looking around for someone to ask for lemon slices and sour cream, as the waiters did not follow up to see if we needed anything, and for some reason our waitress was upset and not friendly. This oversight slightly marred an otherwise enjoyable dining experience.

Overall Experience:

While there were some inconsistencies in the preparation of certain dishes and room for improvement in service, Moondog Cafe & Bakery offers a diverse menu with several standout items. The appetizers and desserts were particularly memorable, and the café’s ambiance added to the overall positive experience. We would recommend giving it a try, especially for the Spinach & Artichoke Dip, Blackened Mahi Tacos, and Key Lime Pie.

We ordered an array of desserts and coffees. We enjoyed everything we got. The Key Lime pie was wonderful (we also bought a full pie to go.) We also really enjoyed the special of the day which was a Mexican chocolate cake. The thing we liked the least was the rum cake and it was still very tasty. We had the best, friendliest service. We will definitely visit again.

5/22/24 - What a find! We had lunch at another restaurant and when we asked how good their key lime pie was the server honestly told us it was pretty good but she'd go to Moondog if we wanted the best key lime pie. We're so glad she did. I've had a lot of key lime pie and the piece I had at Moondog was definitely one of, if not the best. The pie was tart with the sweet merengue perfectly complementing it. My wife got a blueberry bread pudding cheesecake that was delicious but very filling. There were several other wonderful looking baked items that we weren't able to try. We'll make it a point to return to Moondog Cafe anytime we're in Key West. My challenge will be not getting the key lime pie every time so I can try other delicious creations.

Honestly this was the best food and experience we had during our visit! Our waitress was fantastic. (I hate that I don’t remember her name)
I had the BBQ Chicken Pizza - the best pizza I’ve ever eaten! Our son had the John Wayne Burger. I loved watching an 18 year old boast about how great his food was and that the BBQ sauce beat any sauce he has ever had. His friend had the BBQ pork tacos and again 5 stars. The Truffle Mac and Cheese was loved as well.
Don’t forget to try the desserts!! They were all winners! Definitely put this restaurant as a must visit while in Key West!!