Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden

We ate here 3 times on our trip.

I hate to give this place 4 stars instead of 5, but the second time, my fiancee's sandwich had parchment paper in it. The manager explained that this was from the cheese separators, and re-made the sandwich. Still unacceptable. How did the kitchen not notice that? I appreciate the sandwich being remade, but would have more-appreciated them comping the sandwich, considering they had to wait another 10-15 minutes while I had my food.

With that out of the way, each time our food has been excellent(minus the parchment paper), there was very little wait for a table, and the music is excellent. Heard Artic Monkeys, Foster the People, The Strokes, Glass Animals, The Postal Service, Manchester Orchestra, and many more great songs / artists you never get to hear in public.

I can highly recommend the fish and chips, and the chicken stir fry.

Also, they serve food late which is awesome!

Old Town Tavern. Great food, reasonable prices especially at happy hour.
Caribbean jerk wings are awesome, cauliflower bites...great. Ruben spring rolls, pretty darn good. Perfect with a Stella.

Enjoy!

Stopped in for a snack and adult beverage. We got a hazy IPA & and orange wit to drink and snacked on the Reuben egg rolls per the recommendation of the bartender. She was spot on. They were delicious!

Really enjoyed our time at the Beer Graden. Easy to get to, walked in, and sat down on 2 different occasions with no problems. Multiple beers and other drinks to choose from. Service was prompt and courteous. Tried the Scottish Eggs, and that was the best decision I made while in Key West. I would recommend stopping by in your are in Key West.

Delicious food and drinks! The deck was perfect for people watching. The scotch eggs were great, but the real star of the show was the key lime colada!