Tonio's Seafood Shack & Tiki Bar

This place is a nice little stop on the way back from Key West.
They have so many great choices, and different deal most nights.
Sit indoors, or enjoy the covered outdoor seating, with its own Tiki Bar
Thanks to Ashleigh for great service.

Love that the majority of this restaurant's guest chooses the outdoor patio as the atmosphere is great and the live music makes it just that much better. The food is awesome to say the least, and both food and bar are reasonably priced. They serve a Grilled Cheese Crab sandwich that has recently been added to the regular menu. We first had it as one of the daily specials, but when we returned, the sandwich had been placed onto the regular menu, which I wouldn't doubt was done by customer requests. The sandwich was so awesome that we've been back two or three times for that specific entree. There were three of us the first time we tried it, and all three of us returned together each time with our mouths watering, all of us knowing we were going to order that same sandwich, and we did! It has yet to disappoint. Although the sandwich, served as an entree and comes with your choice of one side, is plenty big enough to fill you up, don't be surprised if you are tempted to order an extra one for the table to share or one for yourself to take home, as it honestly is just that good!! The Servers are always on top of their game, and seems each of them has the others back always willing to offer their service when and if needed, and happy to so, always with a smile nonetheless. Definitely one of our favorite places to eat and socialize.
Rhonda Leigh

We we’re staying on Cudjoe Key for a week. Went to Tonio’s for dinner on a Monday night. We had two pastas off the Monday specials menu. We had mussels and littleneck clams for appetizers. Dinner was absolutely amazing!!! We would be here weakly if we lived close. Service was spot on and very attentive considering how busy the place was during our visit. We got an ice cream cookie to go. Tonio’s is highly recommended!

We were on our way to Key west and we found Tonio’s Tiki Bar, where we stopped for lunch. Atmosphere was fantastic, everybody was having fun, music was perfect, you felt on holiday right away. It has a great bar, and other tables on the side, very American and tropical at the same time. Good place to stop! Food was ok, service was perfect super kind and fast, ambient was way too cool. Merry Christmas !!!

My husband and I went to Tonio’s last night and it was soooo good, we decided to sit by the water and the view was spectacular, Manny was our server and did an excellent job at it!!! The fried grouper and shrimp were delicious) there were a few doggies that would bark every once in a while, but other than that the atmosphere was fun and romantic all at the same time. We loved it!