Caragiulo's Italian American

One of the best Italian restaurants I have been to! The food was amazing and the staff very welcoming and professional. Kids had fun making their own pizza.

I come to a business meeting in Sarasota every year and I always make a stop for dinner here because it is the best Italian restaurant in Florida. Everything I’ve had on the menu was absolutely delicious. The service is great and the prices are very reasonable. Hands down, the best part of my trip to Sarasota each year!

Pizza was amazing! Caesar salad was delicious but most of all we had great service! I wish I remembered the names of the bartender and our waiter cause they were so good!

What a wonderful joyful experience! Although I made a reservation for 8, we had a few more and the staff there were so nice and accommodating . The food was delicious and the servers are the best! Best pizza in town!

Caragiulo’s is a gem of restaurant and I’m afraid to share how wonderful my experience was but I won’t be selfish. In fact when you visit you will be greeted by at least one lovely hostess, but I had the pleasure of speaking with two lovely young ladies. One of which I mistaken for the owner, that’s how wonderful she was.
I chose to sit at the bar and my time with both ladies who took very good care of me as well as the locals who arrived after I did. They were both very welcoming, we’re great servers for both the food and drinks and the conversation was a blast.

I had a young fellow that day next to me who placed his order after I did and I knew right away the food would be amazing. We both ordered the same appetizer, he went with a lighter dinner entree than I did, I chose the lobster stuffed ravioli topped with shrimp and it was truly mouth watering.
The couple to my right was cute, she took my dinner recommendation and I hope she enjoyed it S much as I did.

If I didn’t know any better the owners were sitting in the corner admiring the ambiance of the night and I imagined they are very pleased with the making of the beautiful restaurant. I’d rate it a 10 star!!!

*i rated this restaurant the night I ate their a few weeks ago and just now found out it was never posted but my pictures were...user error I’m sure!