Borrillo's Pizzeria and Beer & Wine Garden

The outside area was the best place for me and my kids. It was a clean area with plenty of shade and adequate seating. My kids got the pepperoni pizza and I got the chicken Parmesan. The food was delicious and the portions were huge !!! I had enough for 2 meals. It was our first time and it was an Awesome experience. The building is an old Cottage style gas station from the 1920’s so it was right up my alley. I collect old gas station signs and gas pumps. I was talking with the girl behind the counter and she knew everything about the building and what type of station it was. I told her about the gutters on that style station had a P on them and she chimes in yeah Pure Oil. It gets a 10 in my opinion ????Great food and great architecture????

Little local place... Doesn't look like anything special but their food is GREAT! We all ordered jumbo calzones.... And they're not kidding, these things are huge and very generously filled. The crust was delicious too! Don't bypass this family run gem!

The best pizza in St. Augustine. Fresh ingredients, and great crust. Garlic knots also so delicious.We ordered to go. And was ready when they said for pickup. Small inside eating but still would be worth the wait. We are from Michigan and come down here every year. Employees are very friendly.

Very good! Ordered three 18in pizzas for 11 women on vacation and it was tasty and enough for us. Would have ordered a fourth one if everyone was very hungry, but we weren’t since it was late. Delivery was fast.

Great little pizza place! Surprisingly huge menu with something for everyone. Even though it's only a couple of blocks north of the main tourist area, and almost exactly half way between the fort and the fountain of youth, it's prices are normal, not inflated and the food is superb! They have a nice sit down area inside and a large patio outside offering night time entertainment. A must visit to get away from the tourist crowds for a while and have a real good meal...