Peace Pie

Peace Pie in St. Augustine is a delightful and unique dessert destination that takes the ice cream sandwich to an extraordinary level. This charming little shop, nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, offers a whimsical and nostalgic atmosphere that's instantly inviting.The concept of Peace Pie is simple yet brilliant - layering delicious ice cream with a slab of delectable pie filling between two scrumptious cookies. The variety of flavors is impressive, ranging from classic combinations to more adventurous and creative pairings. Each Peace Pie is a work of art, perfectly balanced in flavor and texture.What makes Peace Pie stand out is not just the quality of their desserts but also the warmth and friendliness of the service. The staff are enthusiastic and helpful, making recommendations and sharing the story behind this unique dessert concept.The shop is clean, cozy, and beautifully decorated, adding to the enjoyable experience. Whether you're a local or a visitor in St. Augustine, stopping at Peace Pie is a must for a memorable and tasty treat that brings a smile to your face.

visited on dec 23rd and the icecream sandwiches were good, the employee was also very sweet and helpful!! i’m not sure what her name was but she was rlly nice.

Was just walking back to Marion when we came across this location. Never would have known if we didn't go down this street. Cool location...pie ice cream with many flavors. I chose the milkshake. Delish 😋 Salted caramel apple...with their signature cookie on top. WoW!!!!!! 100% recommend. Will return for more

So yummy, I get cravings for these all the time! They are special, homemade ice cream sandwiches with Exotic and creative flavors! We love the banana foster or anything with peanut butter! So yummy! They are pretty big so you can split or bring an appetite and it one by yourself!

For $7 per sandwich it is a bit expensive but was a nice treat on a hot day. We shared the cookies and cream but had to wait a bit since it was too hard to bite into. Overall it was enjoyable and worth a visit if you don't want a standard ice cream cone or popsicle for dessert. A couple tables inside and a few outside to sit and eat at. The girl working the counter was friendly and offered to explain the flavor selections and also offered to cut our sandwich in half since we were sharing which was appreciated!