Holy Pie Pizzeria - Port Wentworth

Their food is a step above a fast food pizzeria. The size of the pizza for the price is questionable. I mean does it really cost that much more to make your pies a little bit bigger? I ordered a L and it seemed like a S/M to me. The pizza was very greasy the whole Box had a puddle of grease on it. Also I find it sneaky to automatically add a 15% gratuity to a PICKUP order. It seems like your blindsiding your customers. Why am I even being asked to tip on a pickup order?

Order from here all the time! Love this place! We actually had a mishap on our order and they were amazing and remade the pizza and delivered it in no time! Customer service is on point and you can tell the owners, employees care and that goes a long way!
Hands down best pizza around!
Keep it up! Appreciate y’all!

**Editing to make people aware that the owner personally called us the next day to apologize and make things right. That’s great customer service! That alone deserves a 5 star rating! **

We are literally in a hotel across the street from this restaurant, at the Home2Suites, we called tonight at 7:08 PM, the gal said we could call and order our pizza by 8:30 and no problem. We called at 8:21 am was on hold for a crazy 14 minutes with horrible music. Finally, someone answered and we ordered our pizza which was supposed to be a 14@, hand tossed, extra sauce, extra Italian Sausage, and spinach on one side, mushrooms on the other side. All we got was a mushroom pizza. After driving all day in the nasty weather and insane traffic from NC and after seeing all the rave reviews, this is a huge disappointment. We are here to look for a new home for our new job and location and this is horrible because we can’t even get anyone to answer their phone to make it right! You need to get your employees to take a proper order. I loathe mushrooms. And my husband tipped the driver well because he just didn’t check the order and he’s a good tipper and it’s really not the delivery driver’s fault! Never again. Sorry.
The whole order is wrong!

We eat pizza almost every weekend so we decided to give this place a try, glad we did! Food was delicious, ready on time and they had a very friendly atmosphere. We tried the “family time” special & it’s definitely a ton of food for the price. Give it a try!