Proper Pizza of Idaho

I will start off with a super clean place! I ordered the Macho and man, dang good pizza. Love that the pizza here is not like everything else, they created a new mousetrap when it comes to Pizza that’s for sure! I will be back for sure to try some other flavors. Love the sesame seeds on the crust, nice and flavorful touch.

Such amazing pizza! If you love sesame seeds, it’s a must try. We got 24 inch bbq chicken and Hawaiian and both were delicious. But honestly, the crust and the cheese make it.

So after all the good reviews, we decided to try proper pizza, and I must say it did not disappoint. We got The Italian Job Pizza and I made half of it just pepperoni only. Got an order of the buffalo wings as well. The pizza had a good amount of toppings and if you like thin crust pizza this is a great pizza for you. The pizza had the right amount of sauce on it as well. With the wings the sauce came on the side. So you either had to mix it yourself or dip it. The wings were good quality as well, not greasy nice and crispy and crunchy. They also use use doordash to deliver. I like how they put a seal over the box to know that no one has messed with it. Overall very very good pizza and we will definitely go back for more.

My experience at Proper Pizza exceeded expectations. The Italian Job pizza, the half Crudo and half Proper pizza, along with the garlic bread and chicken wings, left a lasting impression. The combination of great food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere makes this place a standout choice for pizza enthusiasts.

It was my birthday 12/19 and my dad sent me here saying it was the best pizza he ever had in his life. At first I didn't believe but when I tell you I'm a 5ft woman...I ate the whole entire pizza in front of me . It was that good. The sesame on the crust,the thin crust,the taste, the crunch. It was absolute perfection and I will 1000% be dining here again. I live 20min away but I will for sure be eating here again. That should tell you how good it is. They even gave me a birthday cake pastry.