Amici's Pizzeria

Went thru with an order buy phone, a medium supreme pizza and an order of garlic parm wings, pizza and wings were delicious, very very good, but 30 dollars for what looked like small pizza. Great flavor, no complaints except for price, priced too high, but delicious, want to be fair and honest in this review

First time we came we got a deep dish pizza and it wasn’t that good. Came back to give them another try and we got the hand toss pizza which was my favorite and the thin crust and it was really good!! Very quiet place which is perfect for me. Definitely with a try.
Update: They have a pickle pizza, that you need to try!! Substitute the garlic sauce for regular pizza sauce. Trust me! The best pizza I’ve had here I literally tried everything!!

Initially we ordered the Breadsticks, and we were impressed by the crispy exterior and soft and pillowy interior. A good amount of seasoning, and the dipping sauces, cheese and marinara, were delicious. We thought, based on the Breadsticks, we were going to have amazing pizza. Sadly, the pizzas did not meet our expectations. We were dining in, and unsure why the pizzas were brought to the table in pizza boxes. Very strange because the pizzas could have been served on a pizza tray, and saved the boxes for take-out and deliveries. The dough on each of the pizzas was too thick, doughy, and couldn't find the crust. By the looks of the underside of the pizza it looks like it was baked on a plate which prevented the dough from being baked properly. The cheese pizza had a nice balance of red sauce and cheese. The Margarita pizza's base garlic sauce made the dough slimy, and the tomatoes should be cut smaller. Because of the large slices of tomatoes they kept sliding off the pizza. Either cut the tomatoes smaller or put them on top of the cheese, and use a red instead of garlic sauce. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza had far too much Ranch sauce, and made it unpleasant to eat. Next time put the Ranch sauce on the side, and add more Buffalo sauce on the chicken. The desserts we ordered were delicious, but unsure why they were brought to the table at separate times because we ordered them at the same time. The Brownie Pie was fudgy and so delectable. Then the Cinnamon Sticks were brought to our table, and had a wonderful scent of cinnamon. They tasted even better with the drizzle of powdered sugar. Not the pizza experience we were expecting.

We just ordered from Amici’s which is new in Plainfield. We are adventurous people with new places that show up.

This place knocked us out. The pizza was so fresh. We ordered the pickle pizza, which we never had before, and it is really darn delicious! We also ordered the Caribbean pizza, which was our absolute favorite.

I really hope they maintain the quality they have going on. I highly recommend them.