Goodfellas Mass Ave

Pizza by the slice. Old timey bar in the back. Black and white pictures on the wall. Great service. You name it. Definitely one of the best pizza places in the city. Check out the lounge area in the back it’ll take you back to the prohibition era.

This is NOT NY style pizza. This is NOT NY style pizza. Any single person who has been to the east coast and had the great taste of NYC pizza will instantly know the difference. Crust is way to dense and chewy, lack of salty tomato taste, and cheese doesn't to the NYC style drip when you fold it in half.

Once you adjust your mindset, then the pizza is enjoyable and great for late night post bar drinking.

Finding a good New York pizza in Indianapolis was great. Slices are large and have both indoor and outdoor tables. Staff was patient and friendly while we were trying to decide how many slice we want. Walls have pictures from godfather and good fellas movies. Customer base is pleasant covering all age groups while majority is young.

We came in today for lunch - a pretty large group of us, too (parents, damn near a bus load of kids, and a teacher). We were at the firehouse museum down the street and someone suggested we go to Goodfellas for lunch. So we all walked down.
First of all, each and every employee was all smiles and the quick service gets five stars all on its own - even in the thick of a lunch rush and our roughly 16-person crowd, we were in and out in no time).
Secondly, the food. Oh my damn. The pizza was amazing. Five-star pizza all the way. This was my first time in and I'll definitely be bringing my family in at some point (don't worry, there's only three of us lol).

Great service, great food and a clean restaurant. I highly recommend giving Goodfellas a try.
(Sorry for the double picture post - it's not letting me delete the second pic...)

It was good. I used to frequent the location in Lexington, KY. I think the pizza tasted a bit better in Lexington. This place is really nice on the inside and also has nice bathrooms. Service is usually pretty good and consistent. My only complaint for my most recent visit would be the dirty salt shaker.