Lost Hollow Beer Co.

Cannot say enough good things about this place! Unfortunately we were only here for the eclipse so they had a limited menu but it was all amazing! Great patio area, great mixed drinks, fantastic beer selection, and amazing playlist going! If we are ever back in the area we will definitely come back to explore more of the food and drink menu!

A great post Putnam County Swim Meet brunch. Delicious burrito with french fries and house made Black Ale. Excellent first visit and will be back.

Probably one of the best Ruben sandwiches in the Greencastle area, IMHO. Nice place, festive, seems to be quickly becoming a favorite to the locals. Only mis, we ordered an appetizer, which the waitress, served with the main course. We tried a new beer tonight, called the Marzen Ladder. My wife and I both liked it. Not a dark beer, not a hoppy beer, almost best to describe it as a step above a light beer.

Tried their First Friday menu to go and everything was good. I think my shawarma and gyro were missing the sauce but we’re still tasty. Would love to see some cucumber and olives on the gyro. Cuban was great but wished the bun was crispier. Prices were decent but same as inside and you didn’t get the side with it for FF. Interior was beautiful and can’t wait to dine in and try more menu items!

Food was so delicious! The mule was one of my favorites and the old fashioned I could have drank all night! The ambience just completes this place. Lovely rustic venue, great service, and such a friendly staff.
I love the Lost Hollow and can’t wait to come back and bring all my family and friends!