Old Chicago Pizza and Taproom

We have visited here several times. We have never had to wait very long even when it a weekend and prime time. We have tried the calzones and the pizza. Love the Chicago seven hand toss pizza. Best pizza we have had. The best server we have had was devin. She was so attentive and kind. Ask for her section for the best customer service.

Good food and good service once the only waiter was able to get to us. He was working alone but it was 1:00am. I like that they are open till 2:00am when most are closed so there is a late night option. Tea was good!

I made a reservation for dinner last night over a week ago for 6 PM. We were not seated until almost an hour later. There were 12 of us, so talking while waiting is okay with us- but most of us had to stand while waiting because theres not much waiting seating. Other than that, the food was great and our waitress was very good with a big group! Delicious drinks also!

Showed up 30 minutes before close, amazing service, delicious food and good prices. Didn't feel rushed. Everyone was awesome. If you get Paul as a waiter, he's fantastic. Some of the best food in Evansville, and the best late night food without a doubt.

The waiter was so nice. We went on super bowl Sunday but he had a great attitude and did not mind going above and beyond for his tables. Thank you so much. We ordered the large supreme with a medium wing. The waiter made me a strawberry Patron margarita and it was so delicious. Thank you again!