Cuttyhunk Fishing Club

We stayed here when my sister had her wedding on the island. Most amazing nights sleep I ever had. The sounds and smells lull you into a sublime slumber.

Just returned from my first trip to Cuttyhunk and I’m planning to return next summer for a longer visit and will definitely stay at the Cuttyhunk Fishing Club again! The location is great and the views are outstanding. The building is rustic, and the rooms are comfortable each a little different with quirky charm. (Be sure you know what you’re booking, most rooms share bathrooms, which wasn’t an issue for us but may be for some.)

There are a number of common rooms, well appointed with books and games and comfortable seating, and filled with paintings and photographs related to the history of the island and the club. These rooms encourage guests to meet and mingle. Every morning the porch turns into a full breakfast restaurant, attracting a lot of island visitors who aren’t staying at the club — the food is great.. There’s no other food service and there are limited options on the island, but if you bring food with you, you can store it in a shared refrigerator with individual baskets, and prepare it yourself in the kitchen.

Bonnie and her team are very helpful and do a great job providing a friendly, relaxing atmosphere! My daughter, grandson and I all had a wonderful time!

Breakfast overlooking Vineyard Sound & Menemsha, Martha’s Vineyard…
Breathtaking views and a delicious hot breakfast after spending a night on the sailboat. It is a perfect place for breakfast in this beautiful old historic lodge that once hosted President Teddy Roosevelt. The wait can be long… but who really cares with Adirondack chairs overlooking the boats passing by! Cuttyhunk is the best place to do nothing! ~~~~_/),,,,,,,

This place is beyond charming. We were moored for the night in the harbor and walked over first thing for breakfast. They are cash only, but the wait staff was soooo accommodating! (Thank you venmo!) The pancakes are enormous, the croissant fench toast is petite. We came back with at least 9 uneaten pancakes. A little pricy but hey, it's an island!

What a unique and beautiful place. Poised on the point fo Cuttyhunk Island, the sweeping views are outstanding and the experience is both comfortable and private. Watch the sun set and the moon rise while sipping your favorite beverage. The lodge is rustic and FULL of history. If you're seeking a luxury destination...go elsewhere; and miss out on something truly wonderful. If you're looking for a vibrant, historical place to relax, fish, play tennis, boat or whatever you can dream up...this is the place.